Menu of Noel's Pizza 1 in New York, USA
Explore Noel's Pizza 1 menu featuring hand-tossed pizzas, hearty pastas, and fresh salads. Located at 94 Nagle Ave, NYC, enjoy top-rated, affordable flavors praised for quality and quick delivery.
Menu Overview
Noel's Pizza 1, nestled at 94 Nagle Ave in New York City, stands out as a genuine neighborhood gem serving up authentic, flavorful pizza alongside a thoughtfully crafted menu of complementary dishes. This mom and pop pizzeria delivers consistently fresh, well-cooked food with a friendly and professional touch that keeps locals and visitors coming back for more.
The menu offers an impressive range of options beyond the classic pizza pies. Their bread selection features delightful staples such as garlic knots, garlic bread topped with herbs, and the lesser-known but intriguing Zepolis—perfect for those seeking something a bit different to start the meal. The beef patties, both with and without cheese and pepperoni, are generous and filling, reflecting a hearty and satisfying side that complements the main offerings well.
When it comes to the pizzas, the array of options for events is especially noteworthy. Packages like the “2 Medium Cheese Pizza with 10 Wings and 2 Liter Soda” at $52 or the expansive “5 Family Cheese Pizza and 2 Liter Soda” at $110 cater perfectly to gatherings, ensuring plenty of flavor and variety for groups without sacrificing quality. The wings come in multiple flavors—from BBQ to hot—adding a spicy or smoky kick that balances the comforting cheese pizza beautifully.
Customer reviews highlight several remarkable dishes that deserve special mention. The chicken Caesar pizza, especially, has earned high praise for its generous size and exceptional taste—the sort of slice that leaves a lasting impression even on seasoned pizza lovers. The white pie with fresh garlic and buffalo wings is another standout, praised for being tasty and perfectly cooked, showcasing the kitchen’s commitment to well-balanced, satisfying flavor profiles.
Beyond pizza, Noel’s also impresses with dishes like the eggplant Parmesan pasta—a hearty, shareable entrée priced modestly at $13. Its rich, comforting flavors provide a welcome alternative to pizza, broadening the menu’s appeal to diners seeking something more substantial or different.
To round out the dining experience, the tiramisu is a refined dessert choice, capturing the essence of classic Italian flair with layers of coffee-soaked ladyfingers and mascarpone cream, offering a sweet and smooth finish to the meal.
Overall, Noel’s Pizza 1 shines as an approachable, affordable, and consistently high-quality pizza spot. It combines genuine hospitality with a menu that respects traditional Italian-American flavors while providing enough variety to satisfy both casual eaters and connoisseurs. Whether dining in, taking out, or ordering delivery, the experience is reliably positive, making Noel’s a worthy destination for anyone craving well-made pizza and comforting Italian dishes in New York’s Washington Heights neighborhood.
